Tell Me Lies is a well- crafted guilty pleasure that grips you from the very first moment. Adapted from Carola Lovering’s 2018 novel, this Hulu drama unfolds over ten hour-long episodes, each one packed with an array of twists and turns that make it an great choice for your next binge-watching session.
The series introduces us to the toxic love affair between Stephen DeMarco (Jackson White) and Lucy Albright (Grace Van Patten) at a friend’s engagement party, eight years after the tumultuous beginning of their relationship. Created by Meaghan Oppenheimer, Tell Me Lies wastes no time in dropping hints about the turbulent path that Lucy and Stephen's affair is destined to take. From the outset, both Lucy and the audience are cautioned against tumbling down the “Stephen rabbit hole,” a warning that becomes all too real as their eyes lock before the opening credits roll.
While the series teases glimpses of Stephen and Lucy’s tumultuous future, it takes its time unfurling the narrative. The story truly kicks off on Lucy’s first day at Baird College in 2007, where upperclassman Stephen begins his disarming charm by subtly belittling her at a frat party, laying the groundwork for a relationship steeped in unease and discomfort. As the season progresses, you may find yourself surprised by the slow pacing; by the midpoint, we’ve only reached their Christmas break. Yet, despite the early episodes delivering significant shocks, including a sudden death, Oppenheimer employs a methodical approach to the unfolding of this toxic romance. The insidious nature of their relationship creeps up on you, increasing in toxicity almost imperceptibly, until it becomes all too late to turn back.
It’s not often that a show can leave you in a state of uncertainty about its characters, especially after five hourlong episodes. Yet, in this case, the ambiguity surrounding Stephen is not a flaw, but rather a testament to the brilliance of the series. As viewers, we find ourselves on a rollercoaster of emotions. Just when Stephen seems poised to embrace his darker instincts, the narrative pulls back the curtain, revealing a moment of vulnerability or a flicker of kindness that catches us off guard. Conversely, when he starts to charm us with his more appealing traits, the show swiftly reminds us of his chilling capacity for cruelty.
This intricate dance of character development creates a dynamic tension that mirrors the tumultuous journey of Lucy. For years, she finds herself ensnared in Stephen's web, grappling with the complexities of their relationship as she navigates his unpredictable nature. It's this exploration of the psychological intricacies at play within their connection that sets Tell Me Lies apart from other dramas centered on passionate yet ultimately doomed romances. The series delves deep into the nuances of love, manipulation, and the struggle for autonomy, inviting viewers to reflect on the very nature of desire and the sacrifices we make in the name of affection. In doing so, it transforms what could have been a typical love story into a story of human emotion and moral ambiguity.
.jpg) |
| image source: https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/tml_101_js_25550rt-H-2022.jpg |
The subtlety of the performances in this series is a testament to the actors’ ability to embody their characters' unique and often contradictory traits. White shines in the role of Stephen, bringing a magnetic and slippery intensity that captivates viewers. Yet, it is Van Patten's portrayal of Lucy that truly anchors the series. Her blend of vulnerability and resolute self-determination makes her an essential linchpin around which the narrative revolves. As the story unfolds, the show skillfully expands its ensemble cast, presenting characters that defy simplistic categorizations.
Lucy may find her focus drawn toward Stephen, but her evolving friendships with her hallmates, Pippa (Sonia Mena) and Bree (Catherine Missal), are equally compelling and add layers to her character. Their camaraderie is rich and intoxicating, creating a dynamic that breathes life into the story. Even the seemingly superficial character of Wrigley (Spencer House), the hard-partying jock, is granted a moment of depth.
However, the series' holistic approach to character development does have its drawbacks. Certain subplots can languish for extended periods, sometimes to the point where viewers might forget their existence entirely. For example, I found myself surprised when Stephen's family drama resurfaced, having nearly lost track of it since it was first hinted at in earlier episodes.
Within this framework, the affair between Lucy and Stephen begins to unfold, painting a portrait of a young woman who lacks the experience and insight to recognize the complexities of her situation, paired with a young man who is all too aware of how to navigate the emotional landscape to his advantage. Their relationship becomes a battleground, where sex transforms into a means of retaliation against one another. This dynamic becomes a potent tool for Stephen, wielded as a power play. It’s a cruel game, oscillating between frustration and enjoyment, and like all games, it possesses an allure that can be undeniably enticing. Even Stephen’s harshest jabs at his ex, Diana (Alicia Crowder), are often reconfigured into a sharp form of flirtation, illustrating the intricate dance of attraction and disdain.
Ultimately, Tell Me Lies dances on the precipice of romanticizing toxic relationships, with Stephen’s manipulative tendencies extending their reach even to the audience. The ambivalence intricately woven into the narrative prevents it from devolving into sheer melodrama. The series possesses a depth that resists overt moralizing while remaining empathetic to the characters’ struggles. It also offers an unflinching look at the insidious attitudes that provide cover for these relationships, exposing the personal choices and flaws that allow such connections to flourish, as well as the collateral damage they inflict. It emerges as a guilty pleasure in its purest form — an enticing concoction of juicy drama tempered by enough harsh reality to leave a lingering aftertaste.
If you enjoyed this review, don't forget to subscribe so you won't miss out on my next one.
Post a Comment